UK light-heavyweight Buatsi made a winning yet disappointing debut to life under new promoters with a points victory over Zach Parker in Manchester.
The Olympic bronze medallist's activity level appeared to earn him a judges' verdict in a competitive 10-round fight at the Co-op Live Arena.
But Parker landed significant shots, landing some telling clean blows in a contest where the styles didn't complement each other, with constant grabbing marring the action.
The officials had it 96-94 for to the winner, with the third a 95-95 draw.
"It wasn't my best performance but how do champions respond? They win," Buatsi said in the ring as he was faced boos from the crowd.
The Londoner bounced back after his maiden career setback - an memorable fight with Callum Smith in February - to claim a 20th pro success.
Several boxing experts felt Parker, 31, deserved the victory but the British boxer endured the second defeat of his 28-match career.
The Champion Claims Victory in Slow Match
His career development has plateaued in the past few years through promotional disputes and extended periods of lack of fights.
Previously predicted as the future of the British fight scene, he now is positioned trying to achieve expectations - maybe in what seems like a last chance - under fresh management.
He started carefully, with both competitors willing to overcommit in a tentative opening few rounds.
The challenger, whose sole prior loss came at super middleweight against John Ryder in two years ago after breaking his hand mid-fight, was participating in his second appearance at light heavyweight.
By the middle rounds, Parker had made it competitive, creating difficulties for Buatsi, who operated with a protective stance to narrowly win the more effective stanzas.
The audience's tolerance diminished during constant clinching, with the challenger going down various instances during close exchanges.
Parker ended stronger, but several stanzas were difficult to score. However, ex-champion Carl Frampton - providing analysis for the broadcast network - had it significantly in favor for Parker, awarding Buatsi just one round.
The victor advances, but with the caliber of heavy hitter Benavidez, and Eastern European fighter Bivol ruling the division, the path to championship success - based on this performance - still looks steep.
Ricky Hatton Memorial Motivates Local Rivalry Fight
In the secondary fight, Lyndon Arthur beat Bradley Rea by close verdict in a outstanding local rivalry contest to capture the continental belt.
The venue became quiet for a profoundly moving tribute before the fight as 10 bells rang in honor of the city's native Ricky Hatton, who succumbed 46 years old in September.
It was the premier televised match card in the city since the passing of Hatton. As the last bell ended, the silence gave way to a chant of "there's just one Hatton".
The competition during the bout matched the emotion. The eventual winner was sent to the canvas by a left hook directly to the face in the second round, standing uncertainly to his feet on the count of eight.
But the Manchester United-red shorts of Arthur soon came forward again. From the other corner, the opponent - in competitive blue - was injured early, noticeable damage forming under his orbital area as the fighters exchanged powerful shots.
Rea, 27, delivered effective strikes but Arthur, 34, responded in kind with effective uppercuts as the action seldom decreased over the full distance.
Arthur barely secured the verdict with official scores of even score, narrow lead and clearer margin, but the two athletes were determined and courageous, everything their hero Hatton represented.